CITY LIFE!

Does Biopanentheism point us toward a Higher Power?

Does the Hard Problem of Consciousness Point to God?

By Allan W. Janssen

In the ongoing mystery of mind and matter, one question remains persistently unsolved—even by science’s best minds:

"The hard problem of Consciousness is the difficulty in explaining why physical processes in the brain give rise to subjective, qualia-filled experiences like pain or pleasure!"

This is what philosopher David Chalmers famously dubbed the “Hard Problem of Consciousness.” 

While we can map the brain, track neurons, and simulate intelligence, we still can’t explain why a collection of matter should produce the feeling of being alive, aware, and experiencing.

From a purely material standpoint, Consciousness should not exist at all. 

But it does. And that fact opens a door—possibly—to the Divine!

When Science Meets Spirit:

Most scientific theories treat Consciousness as something that emerges from complexity. But that answer merely postpones the question: Why does emergence lead to Awareness?

What if instead, as some philosophers suggest, Consciousness is not a byproduct of biology, but a fundamental feature of reality? 

This is where things start to sound Theological.

Consciousness as Divine Ground:

If Consciousness is fundamental—more basic than matter or space-time—it begins to resemble something sacred. 

Something Eternal! 

Something Divine!

This idea is not new. 

In fact, many religious and philosophical traditions have hinted at it for millennia:

• In Hinduism, Brahman is the infinite field of Awareness that underlies all Being.
• Plotinus described “The One” as the source of all mind and matter.
• Jewish mysticism describes a Divine Light (Ein Sof) hidden within Creation.
• Christian panentheism sees God as both immanent in the world and transcendent beyond it.

Today, modern theories like Integrated Information Theory (IIT) and quantum consciousness models echo this ancient intuition: consciousness is not localized, but woven into the structure of existence itself!

BioPanentheism: Consciousness as God’s Voice:

In my own theological framework, which I call BioPanentheism... Consciousness is not just a product of the Divine... it IS the Divine. 

God is the Living Awareness that permeates all living systems. 

We are not separate from God, but we are waves in God’s ocean of becoming!

The Hard Problem of Consciousness, in this light, is not a bug in the system... it is a signal. 

A clue that the materialist view of the Universe is missing something essential:

The inner light of Awareness is not an accident. It is the signature of something sacred!

The Trailhead to the Divine:

So, does the Hard Problem of Consciousness point to God?

Yes... If you're willing to let “God” mean something deeper than a bearded man in the clouds! 

It means acknowledging that reality itself might be alive, aware, and evolving!

And it means recognizing that your own Awareness—your capacity to ask questions like this—is not just a byproduct of biology... but a glimpse of something Eternal!

---

🔍 Related Reading

• Biopanentheism: A New Theology of Awareness
• Is Consciousness Embedded in the Universe?
• The Divine Spark Theory

Biopanentheism and God!

Biopanentheism is a rather novel and nuanced concept that merges ideas from panentheism and biocentrism. 

Let’s break it down and explore it philosophically and theologically.

1. What is Panentheism?

Panentheism is the view that God is in everything, but also transcends everything. It's different from pantheism, which equates God with the universe. In panentheism, the universe is in God, but God is more than the universe. You might say it tries to preserve both divine immanence and transcendence.

2. What is Biocentrism?

Biocentrism is an ethical viewpoint that gives intrinsic value to all living things, not just human beings. It’s often found in environmental ethics and sometimes overlaps with spiritual perspectives that see life as sacred.

3. So, What is Biopanentheism?

Biopanentheism is a fusion of these ideas: it holds that all life participates in the Divine in some way, perhaps even suggesting that biological life is central to how God relates to the world. 

It's a theological and metaphysical perspective emphasizing that God is intimately present in the processes of life, especially in the biosphere, yet also transcends it.

Often, Biopanentheism is championed by theologians and thinkers seeking to integrate ecological concerns with spirituality, presenting God as deeply involved in the flourishing of life on Earth.

***

Let's see how this can be twisted when looked at from a Christian Perspective!

***

Now, while Biopanentheism might offer an appealing spiritual ecology, it must be evaluated carefully:

• God's Transcendence: Classical Christian theism holds that God is utterly distinct from creation. “In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth” (Genesis 1:1). That affirms that God is not part of the created order, though He is intimately involved in it.

• Christ and Creation: Christianity teaches that God entered creation uniquely in the incarnation — in Christ, not diffusely in all biological life. So, any theology that suggests God is equally incarnate in all life subtly undermines the uniqueness of Jesus Christ.

• Moral Order: Biocentrism, when detached from a theistic framework, can flatten moral distinctions. Christianity affirms that while all life is valuable, human beings are uniquely made in the image of God (Genesis 1:27), with a moral and spiritual calling.

So, while Biopanentheism may seek to affirm God's nearness to life and nature, it must not be allowed to blur the Creator-creature distinction... or the unique redemptive work of Christ. 

It might serve as a conversation starter in ecological theology, but it needs careful discernment to stay aligned with biblical truth.

Let’s compare biopanentheism with biblical theism on several core points, so we can clearly see where they align and where they part ways. 

This is essential because many contemporary spiritualities sound compelling but subtly diverge from the Christian worldview in significant ways.

1. God’s Relationship to the World (P.S. Christianity refers to GOD as "HE" ...in Biopanentheism, God is referred to as "IT" - AWJ)

Biopanentheism:

God is immanent in all life — He dwells in every living thing, and life itself might be a form of divine expression. The divine is seen as evolving or growing with the world.

Biblical Theism:

God is both transcendent and immanent, but not identified with creation. He sustains all things (Colossians 1:17), but He remains distinct from His creation. He is not a part of the world, but He lovingly governs it.

“For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so are my ways higher than your ways.” — Isaiah 55:9

2. View of Creation

Biopanentheism:

Creation, particularly biological life, is Divine, or participates in the Divine, in an essential way. The Divine is “discovered” in nature.

Biblical Theism:

Creation is good, but not Divine. It reflects God’s glory (Psalm 19:1), but it is not God. Nature is a creation, not a manifestation of God's being.

Worshipping the creation rather than the Creator is explicitly condemned in Scripture (Romans 1:25).

3. The Uniqueness of Christ

Biopanentheism:

If God is equally present in all life, then the incarnation of Christ becomes symbolic rather than historical or unique. Jesus may be seen as an enlightened being among many, rather than THE incarnate Son of God.

Biblical Theism:

Jesus is the unique incarnation of God, fully God and fully man. He is not just another expression of Divine presence in the world; He is God come in the flesh (John 1:14), the sole mediator between God and man (1 Timothy 2:5).

4. Salvation and Redemption

Biopanentheism:

Often speaks in terms of harmony, healing, or integration with the cosmos or life-force, rather than moral guilt, sin, and redemption. Salvation might mean ecological balance or inner spiritual awareness.

Biblical Theism:

Salvation is redemption from sin through the atoning death and resurrection of Jesus Christ. It is not achieved by nature, biology, or mystical union with life, but by grace through faith (Ephesians 2:8–9).

5. Moral Framework

Biopanentheism:

Ethics are often derived from what sustains life or the ecosystem — an ecological ethic. It can blur the line between good and evil if everything is seen as part of the Divine process.

Biblical Theism:

Moral values are objective, grounded in the holy nature of God. Good and evil are real distinctions, and God has revealed His moral will through Scripture and the person of Jesus Christ.

Summary

Category	Biopanentheism	Biblical Theism
God& World	God in all life	God is distinct    but present
Creation	Divine participation	Good, but not   Divine
Jesus Christ	One of many expressions	Unique Son of   God
Salvation	Harmony with life	Redemption       through Christ
Morality	Ecological or relational	Rooted in God’s unchanging  character

While Biopanentheism might appear spiritually rich, it ultimately undermines key Christian doctrines, especially the uniqueness of Christ, the nature of sin and salvation, and the distinction between Creator and creation.

SO... RELIGION WILL ALWAYS BE AT ODDS WITH BIOPANENTHEISM... SINCE IT UNDERMINES KEY CHRISTIAN / RELIGIOUS DOCTRINES... AND IS THEREBY A THREAT!!!!!!!